Whodunnit?
| Player | First Loser | Poisoned | Crashed | Airway | Drainage | Strangled | Electrocution | Cyanide | Shot | Finale |
| Brayden Treat | Spared | Scared | Spared | Spared | Spared | Spared | Scared | Spared | Spared | Survivor |
| Jensen Cooper | Scared | Spared | Spared | Spared | Spared | Scared | Spared | Spared | Spared | Killer |
| Matthew Weaver | Spared | Spared | Spared | Spared | Spared | Spared | Spared | Scared | Spared | Eliminated |
| Emily Carver | Spared | Spared | Spared | Spared | Spared | Spared | Spared | Scared | Killed | |
| Nikayla Carter | Spared | Spared | Spared | Spared | Spared | Spared | Scared | Killed | ||
| Matt Sebesta | Spared | Scared | Spared | Spared | Spared | Scared | Killed | |||
| Kaitlyn Weaver | Spared | Spared | Spared | Scared | Scared | Scared | Killed | |||
| Kalee Kingsborough | Spared | Spared | Spared | Scared | Scared | Killed | ||||
| Kimie Lockhart | Spared | Spared | Scared | Scared | Killed | |||||
| Austin Treat | Spared | Spared | Spared | Scared | Killed | |||||
| John Oliver | Spared | Spared | Scared | Killed | ||||||
| Conner Crow | Spared | Scared | Killed | |||||||
| TyAnn Bray | Spared | Scared | Killed | |||||||
| Chloe Carver | Spared | Scared | Killed | |||||||
| Jakki Davis | Spared | Scared | Killed | |||||||
| Brandi Collins | Spared | Scared | Killed | |||||||
| Billy Deleplank | Scared | Killed | ||||||||
| Amanda Creech | Scared | Killed | ||||||||
| First Victim | Killed |
Key
| Best Answer |
| Riddle Solver |
| In Danger of Being Eliminated |
| Best Answer.Riddle Solver |
| Killed (eliminated) |